No. On 18 November 2026 only two of the three Faymas domains ever returned 304 Not Modified, and those two disagreed on what "unchanged" means. faymas.in returned 304 for any If-Modified-Since date at or after its own Last-Modified, including a date one day in the future. faymas-in.com returned 304 only for the exact date string it had sent, and 200 for one second later. faymas.net returned 200 to every conditional request we sent. Not one of the three HTML pages carried an ETag, though a CSS file on each did. Every request shape was repeated three times. Every repeat came back identical.
This guide analyses published prompt text. No generation tests were run.
What was already counted, and what was not
An earlier audit on this site, published on 20 October 2026, counted response headers across 106 successful requests to four Faymas domains. It found exactly one ETag in all 106. It listed validators per domain: 35 of 61 responses on faymas.in, 0 of 25 on faymas.net, 9 of 9 on faymas-in.com, and 1 of 11 on a fourth domain. That page asked whether a header was present. It never sent one back.
This page does. A validator sitting in a response is a noun. Using it is a verb.
We worked with the three fixed competitor domains only: faymas.in, faymas.net and faymas-in.com. We requested each one's canonical host over https, with no redirect followed. The canonical hosts are the ones measured on 17 November 2026: the apex for faymas.in, www for faymas.net, the apex for faymas-in.com. We sent one plain GET first, then sent its own validator back as a conditional request. Three repeats per shape. All requests came from one machine on one morning.
No HTML page carries an ETag. Every CSS file does.
Three HTML home pages, three missing ETags. Two of them do send Last-Modified instead. The split is clean.
| Domain | HTML ETag | HTML Last-Modified | CSS ETag | CSS cache-control |
|---|---|---|---|---|
faymas.in | absent | Wed, 18 Nov 2026 01:12:00 GMT | W/"3e9da-1a1eaa24ee0" | public, max-age=31536000, immutable |
faymas.net | absent | absent | "4abab4668c7afdaba0d0fed32276dfdb" | public,max-age=31536000,immutable |
faymas-in.com | absent | Tue, 17 Nov 2026 17:33:03 GMT | W/"de62-6afce775-fc62577f384fcd13;br" | public, max-age=604800 |
The image-weight audit of 21 October 2026 already recorded those immutable declarations on output images, and noted one faymas.net logo served with max-age=0, must-revalidate. It recorded what the server says. We recorded what the server does when you hold that declaration up to it. The faymas.in CSS came back as a cache HIT with an age of 26,088 seconds, roughly seven hours of stored lifetime. A year of declared immutability and seven hours of observed age are different facts. Both are on the wire.
The ETags on those CSS files are real. They are not decoration. We tested them below.
The same timestamp gets two different answers
Take the Last-Modified string each domain handed us. Move it one second either way. Then a day. Here is what came back, three times per cell, with no unstable cell anywhere in the table.
| If-Modified-Since | faymas.in | faymas-in.com |
|---|---|---|
| Last-Modified minus 1 second | 200 | 200 |
| Last-Modified exactly | 304 | 304 |
| Last-Modified plus 1 second | 304 | 200 |
| Last-Modified plus 1 hour | 304 | 200 |
| Last-Modified plus 1 day | 304 | 200 |
Both domains refuse a date before their own. Both accept the exact string. Then they part. faymas.in accepts anything later: one second, one hour, one day, and a fixed date in 2031. faymas-in.com rejects all three later offsets. It gave 304 to a date in the future zero times out of three.
We cannot read the server code. The pattern is consistent with a timestamp comparison on one domain and an exact-string comparison on the other. HTTP semantics expect the first. Neither behaviour is a bug we can prove. We report the codes and label the interpretation as an interpretation.
One small detail sits inside the faymas-in.com 304. Its 200 response carries no cache-control at all. Its 304 adds no-cache, must-revalidate plus an expires equal to the response date. The shorter answer says more about caching than the long one.
If-None-Match overrides on one domain and is ignored on the other
RFC 9110 gives If-None-Match precedence. When it is present, a server should ignore If-Modified-Since. We sent both headers together, with a deliberately wrong ETag and the correct date.
| Request headers | faymas.in | faymas-in.com |
|---|---|---|
| Wrong If-None-Match + exact If-Modified-Since | 200 | 304 |
If-None-Match: * + exact If-Modified-Since | 200 | 304 |
| Exact If-Modified-Since only (control) | 304 | 304 |
Same two headers. Same minute. Opposite outcomes. On faymas.in the presence of an If-None-Match cancels the date and the wrong ETag forces a full 200. On faymas-in.com the ETag header is ignored and the date still wins. Add a star instead of a wrong ETag and the split holds. Again, three repeats each, all identical.
We label that as an inference too. What we observed is the status line, not the branch in somebody's code.
What a 304 actually contains
A 304 has no body. That is the point of it. The measured bodies were 593,617 characters of HTML on the faymas.in 200 and 71,239 on the faymas-in.com 200. Both 304 responses carried zero. Every one of those characters stayed on the server.
The headers tell a less obvious story. faymas.in's 304 keeps cf-cache-status: HIT, its age of 161, the same private, max-age=300, must-revalidate, the same vary list, and via: 1.1 Caddy. It drops content-type and transfer-encoding. Nothing else moves. The cached object is still a cached object.
faymas-in.com's 304 keeps cf-cache-status: DYNAMIC and its LiteSpeed and PHP signatures. It also adds two headers the 200 never sent. We said them above. A response that says nothing changed is allowed to say more about caching than the full page did. It did here.
HEAD and GET disagree about the same URL
This one was not in the plan. A plain GET to faymas.in returns private, max-age=300, must-revalidate with cf-cache-status: HIT and a growing age. A plain HEAD to that identical URL returns private, no-cache, no-store, max-age=0, must-revalidate with cf-cache-status: DYNAMIC. Three HEAD requests, three identical answers.
Same URL. Two methods. Two cache policies. We do not know which layer emits the HEAD response, so we leave it as a measurement.
Request-side cache directives did nothing either. Adding Cache-Control: no-cache or Pragma: no-cache to our GET still produced 200, still HIT, and the age kept climbing through 49, 50 and 51. The edge kept its stored copy.
Then there is faymas.net. No ETag. No Last-Modified. No cf-cache-status at all. Its header reads private, no-cache, no-store, max-age=0, must-revalidate. We sent wrong ETags, a star ETag, past dates, future dates, both together, and request-side no-cache. Every one returned 200. There is nothing there to revalidate, and the domain says so in plain words. The 20 October audit recorded 0 of 25 validators on this domain. Nothing changed.
The CSS ETags work, with one exception
HTML has no ETag on any of the three. CSS does on all three. So we used those ETags.
| Condition on the CSS file | faymas.in | faymas.net | faymas-in.com |
|---|---|---|---|
| If-None-Match, exact ETag | 304 | 304 | 304 |
If-None-Match: * | 304 | 200 | 304 |
| If-None-Match, wrong ETag | 200 | 200 | 200 |
| If-Modified-Since, exact date | 304 | not tested; no date sent | 304 |
Exact ETag: 304 on all three, three times each. Wrong ETag: 200 on all three, three times each. The star form is where they split. A star means "if any current representation exists". faymas.in and faymas-in.com accepted it. faymas.net did not, and returned 200 three times out of three. The faymas.net CSS sends no Last-Modified, so the date condition was not tested there. We write "not tested" rather than guessing.
So the immutable declaration from October is not the end of the story. An asset advertised as unchanging for a year still answered a conditional request with a 304 on two domains. Declaration and behaviour are separate columns.
What we did not test
- Only the three fixed domains, their canonical hosts and the root path, plus one CSS file each.
- We did not follow redirects. We did not send POST, and did not test how a 308 preserves a body.
- We did not test QUIC or UDP 443, browser cache behaviour after JavaScript runs, cache lifetime after expiry, or any second vantage point.
- Single outbound network, one resolver, one morning. The 304 status lines read HTTP/1.1.
- We did not identify owners, origin servers, accounts or registration details. No traffic, ranking or revenue figures appear here.
- The two comparison logics and the header-precedence difference are interpretations of status codes, not source-code proof.
If you want to know whether a Faymas page changed, do not ask for an ETag. None of the three HTML pages has one. Take the Last-Modified string the page itself handed you, send it back, and read the status line. Whether you get 304 depends on which domain you asked, not on whether anything changed. A header can be present and still never be used. On these three domains the only way to tell is to send it back.
FAQ
Do any of the three Faymas domains send an ETag on its HTML page?
No. On 18 November 2026 all three HTML home pages omitted ETag, though a CSS file on each domain carried one.
Which Faymas domain always answers 200 to a conditional request?
faymas.net. Its HTML sends no ETag and no Last-Modified, and every If-None-Match or If-Modified-Since request we sent returned 200.
Does faymas.in return 304 for a date in the future?
Yes. If-Modified-Since one day after its own Last-Modified returned 304 three times out of three.
Does faymas-in.com return 304 for a date one second after its Last-Modified?
No. It returned 200 three times out of three; only the exact date string produced 304.
How much body does a 304 send?
Zero. The faymas.in 200 carried 593,617 characters of HTML and its 304 carried none; faymas-in.com went from 71,239 to zero.